The Second Deadline: What Early Decision II Offers, and What It Doesn’t

November 5, 2026

Early Decision II usually gets described in one of two ways. Either it is a new trend sweeping admissions, or it is a second chance, a do-over for students whose first early application did not work out. The data supports neither description very well.

It is not new, at least not at the selective colleges that publish detailed admissions data. Among 70 early decision colleges whose Common Data Set filings we could read in every edition from 2019-20 through 2025-26, 46 already listed a second early decision deadline at the start of that span. By the 2025-26 edition, 50 did.

And it is a second chance only in a narrow sense. At the four colleges we found that publish admit rates for both rounds, the ED II rate was less than half the ED I rate in each case. Grinnell admitted 48 percent of its ED I applicants for the Class of 2029 and 18 percent of its ED II applicants.

Those findings answer two different questions, and families care most about a third. The Common Data Set gives solid evidence on how common ED II has become. A handful of colleges’ published figures describe how ED II compares with ED I. Neither source can say whether applying ED II raises a particular student’s chances compared with applying regular decision, and this article does not claim to answer that.

The practical takeaway comes first, then. ED II makes sense for a student who has settled on a clear first choice by early January and whose family can commit to it financially. It is not a statistical shortcut, and the published numbers do not show that it works as one.

Counting the Second Deadline

No national count of colleges offering ED II exists. The National Association for College Admission Counseling lists early decision usage as an upcoming topic for its State of College Admission report. The Common Data Set comes closest. Item C21 asks every reporting college for its first early decision closing date and for the closing date of any “other early decision plan.” The form never uses the term ED II, so a second date is a proxy for one.

We pulled item C21 from roughly 2,200 Common Data Set files in the College Transitions repository, covering the 2018-19 through 2025-26 editions. Many files could not be read cleanly in every year, so the trend in Figure 1 uses a fixed panel of 70 colleges that offered early decision and filed a readable C21 in all seven editions from 2019-20 on. The panel starts in 2019-20 because the repository holds fewer files for 2018-19. Starting a year earlier yields a panel of 68 colleges and a similar pattern, rising from 61.8 percent to 70.6 percent.

Figure 1. Share of 70 early decision colleges listing a second early decision deadline, by Common Data Set edition. Source: College Transitions analysis of CDS item C21.

The share moved from 65.7 percent to 71.4 percent over seven editions, and most of that change came early. Forty-five of the 70 colleges listed a second deadline in every edition, and 18 never did. Only seven changed status. Connecticut College, Texas Christian University and Villanova first listed a second round in the 2021-22 edition, Loyola Marymount listed one in 2020-21 and again from 2023-24 on, and St. Mary’s College of Maryland added one in 2025-26. Two colleges stopped listing a second date. The College of New Jersey did so from the 2022-23 edition and Baylor from 2024-25.

The colleges that never listed a second round are a recognizable group. Amherst, Dartmouth, Northwestern, Penn and Williams appear on that list, along with Barnard and Case Western Reserve. At the most selective end of the panel, a single early decision round remains common.

The panel has limits that readers should keep in view. It includes only colleges that publish a Common Data Set and whose files we could read in every edition, so it leans toward established, selective private colleges and is not a sample of all U.S. colleges. Some well-known ED II colleges, including Pomona, Vanderbilt and the University of Chicago, fell out because at least one year’s file could not be read. Growth is also happening outside the panel. Rice announced its first ED II round for the 2024-25 cycle, Fordham added one for students applying in fall 2023, and Boston College replaced early action with two rounds of early decision beginning with students applying in fall 2019. College Transitions also maintains a broader list of colleges offering Early Decision 2, last updated in October 2021.

The Second Round Is the Smaller Door

The Common Data Set combines both early decision rounds into one applicant count and one admit count, so it cannot show how ED II compares with ED I. For that, we searched admissions offices, official news releases and campus newspapers for nearly 90 colleges that offer ED II or were reported to. Four published admit rates for both rounds in the same cycle. Figure 2 shows all four, each from the most recent year we could find, so the chart compares rounds within each college rather than describing a single admissions year.

Figure 2. ED I and ED II admit rates at the four colleges that published both, most recent comparable year for each. Emory figures cover Emory College of Arts and Sciences only. Not a representative sample.

The gap appears at all four. Grinnell’s ED II rate was 18 percent against 48 percent in ED I. Emory College of Arts and Sciences admitted 31 percent of ED I applicants and roughly 12 percent of ED II applicants for the Class of 2027, according to The Emory Wheel. Vanderbilt admitted 24.1 percent in ED I and 10.3 percent in ED II for the Class of 2026, as reported by The Vanderbilt Hustler. Rice’s first ED II round, for the Class of 2029, admitted 6 percent of 2,513 applicants, against 13.2 percent in ED I, according to The Rice Thresher.

Four colleges are a small and possibly unusual group. Colleges choose whether to release round-specific numbers, and nothing guarantees that the ones that do resemble the dozens that do not. The pattern is consistent across the four, but it describes those four, not ED II colleges in general.

Colleges do not attribute the gap to a penalty for applying later. Sarah Fischer, Grinnell’s assistant vice president of admission, told The Scarlet & Black that “There’s no advantage to applying one over the other,” and said the difference comes down to the composition of the applicant pool in each round. Vanderbilt admissions dean Doug Christiansen told the Hustler in 2024 that the two pools’ acceptance rates and applicant numbers were largely the same, in the paper’s paraphrase, while declining to release separate figures.

Two colleges publish enough to follow the second round over several years.

College Class ED II applicants ED II admits ED II admit rate ED I admits
Johns Hopkins 2025 2,874 304 10.6%* 520
Johns Hopkins 2026 Over 3,000 301 – 520
Johns Hopkins 2027 – 278 – 533
Johns Hopkins 2028 – 259 – 550
Johns Hopkins 2029 – 242 – 551
Johns Hopkins 2030 – 260 – 553
Emory College 2026 1,817 259 – –
Emory College 2027 2,088 245 Roughly 12% 722
Emory College 2028 2,147 267 12% 705
Emory College 2029 – 235 10% –

Table 1. ED II results at Johns Hopkins and Emory College of Arts and Sciences over time. Emory figures exclude Oxford College. Sources listed at the end of the article. Dashes mark figures the college or newspaper did not report. *Computed by College Transitions from published counts.

Johns Hopkins admitted 304 students through ED II in its first year with the round, for the Class of 2025, from 2,874 applicants, a rate of 10.6 percent by our calculation. Its ED II admits have since ranged from 242 to 260 a year while its ED I admits rose from 520 to 553. At Emory College of Arts and Sciences, the ED II applicant pool grew from 1,817 to 2,147 over two cycles while admits stayed between 245 and 267, and the reported ED II rate slipped from roughly 12 percent to 10 percent by the Class of 2029. Emory’s university-wide ED II totals, which include Oxford College, are larger, and the table does not mix the two.

ED II Versus Regular Decision

A lower ED II rate than ED I rate does not mean ED II is a poor choice. The comparison a student faces in January is between ED II and regular decision, and that comparison is much harder to make.

The pools differ. ED II applicants include students who were deferred or denied in a first round elsewhere and students who applied ED I to a more selective college. Regular decision pools include everyone else, from the most competitive applicants to the least. A college that applied identical standards in every round would still post different rates in each. Published rates describe pools, not the odds facing any one applicant.

The available figures point in different directions. Rice admitted 7.8 percent of all 36,777 applicants to the Class of 2029, according to the Thresher, a figure that includes both early rounds and still exceeds the 6 percent ED II rate. Grinnell, on the other hand, reports on its early decision page that over four years it admitted 53 percent of ED I and ED II applicants combined and 11 percent of regular decision applicants. Neither figure isolates what ED II itself adds for a given student. Some colleges also attach money to an early commitment. An undated Grinnell admissions page says domestic students admitted early decision are guaranteed a minimum scholarship of $20,000 a year.

What families can take from this is narrow. ED II lets a student signal a binding first choice, which admissions officials describe as useful in building a class. How much that signal changes an individual student’s chances is not measured by any data we found.

Why Colleges Keep a Second Round

Admissions officials describe ED II in two ways. The first is timing. William & Mary’s dean of admission, Tim Wolfe, told The Flat Hat in 2018 that the round serves students who decide the college is their first choice “in that window between Nov. 1 and Jan. 1.” Rice’s vice president for enrollment, Yvonne Romero da Silva, told The Rice Thresher in 2024 that some students “may want to have a strong performance in their senior year factor into the consideration of their application file.”

The second is enrollment planning. In the same Thresher interview, Romero da Silva said that “ED II will help us maintain our target enrolling populations.” Students admitted through either early decision round agree to enroll, which lets a college fill a predictable share of its class before regular decision begins. Our June 2026 analysis, The Early Decision Machine, found that the share of incoming classes filled through early decision at 362 selective colleges rose from 31.9 percent in the 2022-23 cycle to 34.6 percent in 2024-25. A second round adds another set of committed students to that share.

The commitment is binding, though some colleges spell out an exception for affordability. Hamilton, for example, says it will release admitted students from the agreement “if they determine Hamilton is not affordable for their families.” That release exists for genuine affordability problems. It is not a way to collect and compare aid offers, and families should run a college’s net price calculator before applying.

The January Calendar

Timing is where ED II matters most to families, because it falls just after most first-round early results arrive. MIT released its early action decisions on December 16, 2025, and Yale announced its early results the next day. A student deferred or denied in mid-December has, at most ED II colleges, between two and four weeks to decide where to apply next.

Figure 3. ED II closing dates for 75 colleges, from their 2025-26 Common Data Set filings, with corrections noted on the chart. Confirm current deadlines with each college.

Of the 75 colleges in Figure 3, 71 set their ED II deadline between January 1 and January 15. January 15 was the most common date, with 25 colleges, followed by January 5 with 17 and January 1 with 11. Three colleges, St. Lawrence, Texas Christian and Trinity University in San Antonio, use February 1, and DePauw uses December 15, which leaves almost no time after mid-December results.

Common Data Set dates are self-reported and can lag a college’s current policy. We checked every December and February date against the colleges’ admissions websites. Reed’s filing listed December 20, but its website gives January 15. Lafayette’s filing listed February 1, which is the date by which regular decision applicants can switch to ED II, while its ED II application deadline is January 15. Allegheny’s filing listed a February 1 date, but its current admissions page shows a single early decision round, so it is left out of the chart. Treat Figure 3 as a planning map and confirm each date on the college’s own site. The interactive version lists the colleges behind each date.

What a December result means for ED II depends on whether it was a denial or a deferral. A student denied in a first early decision round is free to apply ED II elsewhere. A student deferred from a first early decision round moves into that college’s regular pool, and many colleges release deferred students from the binding agreement. Hamilton and Barnard both say so on their admissions pages. Check the first college’s policy before applying ED II somewhere else. A student admitted ED II must then withdraw every other pending application, including one where a deferral is still under review.

A Decision Path for December

For a student deferred or denied in a first early round, the choice about ED II comes down to four questions, in this order.

Is there a college you would attend over every other option still open to you?

ED II is binding. If the answer is no, apply regular decision and keep every option open until spring. A student who is not sure should not trade flexibility for a round whose advantage over regular decision has not been measured.

Does that college offer ED II, and when is the deadline?

Check the college’s own admissions page rather than relying on last year’s date or a Common Data Set filing. Most deadlines fall in the first half of January, but a few fall in December or February. A student deferred elsewhere should also confirm whether that deferral released them from the first college’s agreement.

Would the student be competitive there in regular decision?

Use the college’s overall and early decision admit rates from its Common Data Set as a rough guide, and expect any ED II rate the college publishes to be lower than its ED I rate. A binding application signals commitment, but no published data shows how much that signal is worth for an individual applicant, so ED II is not a reason to apply to a college that would otherwise be a long shot.

Can the family commit before seeing other financial aid offers?

Run the college’s net price calculator before applying. An ED II admit is expected to withdraw other applications, which ends the chance to compare aid packages in the spring. Some colleges, Hamilton among them, release admitted students who cannot afford to attend, but that release is a safeguard, not a plan. If affordability depends on comparing offers, regular decision preserves that option.

A student who answers yes to all four has a strong case for ED II. A student who hesitates on any of them keeps more flexibility, and the chance to compare financial aid offers, by applying regular decision.

Methodology: College Transitions extracted Common Data Set item C21 from the 2018-19 through 2025-26 editions in the College Transitions CDS repository (about 2,200 files), using text extraction, PDF form fields and Excel cell reads, with page images checked by hand where values were flattened into the page. A college counts as listing a second early decision round in an edition when it reported an “other early decision plan closing date” distinct from its first date. Figure 1 uses the 70 colleges that offered early decision and had a readable C21 in every edition from 2019-20 through 2025-26; this panel is not representative of all U.S. colleges. Figure 3 uses 2025-26 filings, with every December and February date checked against admissions websites in November 2026; Reed and Lafayette were corrected and Allegheny was omitted, as noted. Round-specific admit rates come from colleges’ own releases and from campus newspapers citing admissions officials, gathered in November 2026 from searches covering nearly 90 colleges; every figure was checked against its source page. The Johns Hopkins rate for the Class of 2025 was computed by College Transitions from the published counts. A downloadable workbook with the 70-college panel, each college’s status by edition, and the 75 deadline dates accompanies this article.

Sources